Punishments of the Sons of Corah by Sandro Botticelli

Where? On the south wall of the Sistine Chapel in the Vatican Museums
When? 1481-1482
Commissioned by? Pope Sixtus IV
What do you see? The punishment of Corah (also spelled Korah), Dathan, and Abiram because they opposed the leadership of Moses. There are three different scenes:

• The scene on the right: The Levites attempt to stone Moses, who is the man on the complete right with the long beard. However, Joshua, the man with the white sleeves, holds them back. You can see that the two people to the left of Joshua are holding stones in their hands. Moses raises his right hand as a sign that God will punish those who rebel against him.
• The scene in the middle: Moses, Aaron, and six of the rebellious Israelites (including the sons of Aaron) want to burn their incense dishes as a gift to God. Aaron is the man behind the altar dressed in blue and wearing the papal tiara. Two sons of Aaron are behind the altar and in between Moses and Aaron is the third son of Aaron. The three men on the left are Corah, Dathan, and Abiram. Smoke comes from the incense dish of priest Aaron and goes up to Heaven. The smoke of the rebels does rise to Heaven and rather attacks them at the command of Moses who raises his rod.
• The scene on the left: Moses raises his right arm, and the earth swallows the rebellious Israelites, Corah, Dathan, and Abiram (of whom two are depicted). Above them, two people stand on a cloud, which are the two sons of Corah who are saved from the punishment.

The arch in the back is the Arch of Constantine. In the attic of this Arch, a text from Hebrews 5:4 is inscribed: “To be a high priest is an honor. But no one chooses himself for this work. That person must be chosen by God just as Aaron was.” This text directly refers to the three scenes in this painting. However, this text is not inscribed in the real Arch of Constantine.

Backstory: This painting is part of a series of frescos on the stories of Moses on the south wall of the Sistine Chapel. This series includes another fresco of Botticelli, which is Youth of Moses. The fresco on the Punishments of the Sons of Corah is based on three different stories from the Bible.

• The first one is the attempt to Stone Moses, described in Numbers 14:10. The Israelites were unhappy that they would have to fight against an enemy to conquer their promised land and were afraid to die in that fight.
• The second scene is a combination of two stories. The first story is in Leviticus 10 and describes the killing of the sons of Aaron after they do not use sacred fire to burn their incense. The second story is based on Numbers 16:7, in which Moses asks Corah, Dathan, and Abiram to burn their incense in a special pan for God.
• The third scene is based on Numbers 16. Corah, Dathan, and Abiram sinned against God, and God decided that they would have to die differently than normal people. The earth opened and swallowed these three men, their families, and everything they owned.

Youth of Moses by Botticelli

What is the Arch of Constantine? It is the largest triumphal arch in Rome. It was built to commemorate the victory in 312 AD of Roman Emperor Constantine I over another Roman Emperor, Maxentius, during a time in which there were multiple emperors in the Roman Empire. The arch is located next to the Colosseum.

​The arch is 21 meters (23 yards) high and has three entrances as you can see in this painting. Roman Emperors walked under this arch when they entered the city after a victory. The Arch of Constantine is also depicted twice in the Delivery of the Keys by Perugino which is on the north wall of the Sistine Chapel in the Vatican Museums.

Delivery of the Keys by Perugino

Symbolism: This fresco illustrates the claim of power of the Catholic Church and the papacy. It shows that only priests can perform holy duties and that God will punish people if they do not obey him. It also shows that God saves the people who obey Him. The Arch of Constantine is included to symbolize the victory of Christianity over paganism. The inscription from Hebrews 5:4 shows the holiness of the Pope as he was chosen by God.
​
Who is Botticelli? Sandro Botticelli was born in Florence in 1445 under the name Alessandro di Mariano di Vanni Filipepi. His father apprenticed Sandro to a goldsmith such that he could soon start making money for the family. As there was a close connection between goldsmiths and painters, Botticelli was able to become familiar with painting and discovered that this was his passion. He became an apprentice of Fra Filippo Lippi, one of the greatest painters of that time.

​Botticelli is best known for his famous paintings of The Birth of Venus and La Primavera, which are both in the Uffizi Museum.

The Birth of Venus by Botticelli

La Primavera by Botticelli

​Fun fact: Note that in all three scenes, Moses has light rays coming out of his head, which he got after meeting God on Mount Sinai. The rays signify the grace of God. There are ten rays of light in each beam, which is equal to the Ten Commandments that Moses received from God.

​In many other depictions of Moses, he has horns on top of his head, but this seems to be a mistake due to an incorrect transcription of Exodus 34:29-30. The reason is that the Hebrew word for ‘qaran’ or ‘keren’ can be translated both by ‘horn’ or ‘ray of light’ and in some of the 15th-century translations the word horn was used. For example, look at the horns on the statue of Moses by Michelangelo in the San Pietro in Vincoli church in Rome.

Moses by Michelangelo

---

Written by Eelco Kappe

References:

• Knutsen, Susan N. (1984), Botticelli's Sistine Frescoes, Thesis, University of Arizona.
• ​www.frankvandenbroeke.com/religion/pinacoteca/light-in-art-the-horns-of-moses.html